Skip to content

Court docket Orders US Navy to Pay $154,400 in Software program Piracy Damages * TorrentFreak

house > Lawsuits >

The USA Navy should pay $154,400 in copyright infringement damages to German software program firm Bitmanagement. The US Court docket of Federal Claims awarded the compensation after the Navy was proven to have copied and used software program with out permission. Whether or not Bitmanagement will rejoice this win is up for query because the damages are lower than 0.1% of the $155 million it requested for.

Six years in the past, the US Navy was sued for mass copyright infringement and accused of inflicting a whole lot of thousands and thousands of {dollars} in damages.

The lawsuit was filed by German firm Bitmanagement. It wasn’t a typical piracy case the place software program was downloaded from shady sources, however the finish end result was the identical.

It began in 2011 when the US Navy started testing Bitmanagement’s 3D digital actuality utility ‘BS Contact Geo’. The Navy subsequently put in the software program throughout its community, assuming that it had permission to take action.

This turned out to be an important misunderstanding. Bitmanagement mentioned it by no means approved such a use and when it found that the Navy had put in the software program on a whole lot of 1000’s of computer systems, the corporate took authorized motion.

Bitmanagement Wins Enchantment

In a grievance filed at the USA Court docket of Federal Claims in 2016, the German firm accused the US Navy of mass copyright infringement and demanded damages totaling a whole lot of thousands and thousands of {dollars}.

bs contract

The Court docket initially dismissed the grievance so Bitmanagement appealed. Final yr, the Court docket of Appeals for the Federal Circuit sided with the German software program firm, concluding that the US Authorities was certainly liable.

The matter was reverted again to the Federal Claims courtroom, to find out the suitable damages quantity by a ‘hypothetical negotiation’ course of at a behind-closed-doors trial.

Thousands and thousands or 1000’s in Damages?

Over the previous a number of months, the courtroom heard either side and an important knowledgeable witness. The aim was to determine what the Navy would have paid for the software program licenses if an settlement had been reached.

The courtroom additionally needed to determine what number of copies the Navy ought to pay compensation for. Bitmanagement claimed that over 600,000 copies have been put in however the Court docket of Appeals specified that damages ought to be primarily based on “precise utilization” of the software program.

To succeed in its ultimate verdict the Federal Claims Court docket relied partly on testimony from the Navy’s knowledgeable witness, David Kennedy, who has huge expertise with establishing damages claims.

After reviewing numerous log information, Mr. Kennedy concluded that the software program was used by a couple of hundred distinctive customers at most. As well as, he believes that it is cheap that Bitmanagement would have agreed to a value of as much as $200 per license.

This determine is decrease than the $370 per set up that was negotiated earlier. Nevertheless, the knowledgeable witness believes that that is warranted as a result of massive quantity of the deal and the truth that the software program firm’s money place was reasonably low on the time.

Court docket Awards $154,400

Federal Claims Court docket Decide Edward J. Damich largely agrees with this knowledgeable opinion. In his order, he awards $154,400 in whole damages.

bit management

The injury determine relies on 635 distinctive customers and a license charge of $200. The courtroom additionally awards a further $350 for every of the 100 simultaneous-use licenses the Navy would have agreed to.

Decide Damich notes that these conclusions are supported by “goal issues”, including that the injury quantity is “honest and cheap”.

Whether or not Bitmanagement agrees with this conclusion has but to be seen. The corporate requested $155 million in damages, arguing that the Navy has put in 600,000 copies of its software program, for which it ought to have paid ~$259 a bit.

The $154,400 in compensation represents a tiny fraction of the declare, even when we add an award for delayed compensation, which can be established later.

A replica of the Federal Claims Court docket’s order, granting Bitmanagement $154,400 in copyright infringement damages is offered right here (pdf)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *