Skip to content

Guidewire Software program: Promote Into The Buyback (NYSE:GWRE)



As rates of interest go up and the tide of simple cash recedes, firms that grew at any value are taking it on the chin. The period of profitless prosperity is coming to an finish. In the previous few months, I’ve highlighted plenty of these, from WeWork (WE) to GitLab (GTLB).

Firm managements confronted with a halving of their inventory worth and a restive workforce watching their holdings lose worth have a selection. They will concentrate on profitability by reducing prices, and exhibiting the market that they are surely offering some financial worth to their clients. Or they will use the money steadiness they stockpiled in the course of the good instances to do a bit of monetary engineering and purchase again their inventory. Alas, the latter is only a momentary repair. In some unspecified time in the future, the money steadiness will probably be depleted, and the main focus will as soon as once more be on earnings. That is the trail that Guidewire Software program (NYSE:GWRE) has chosen, with the announcement of a $400 million share repurchase.

Normally when an organization declares a buyback, it is a chance to purchase the inventory as the corporate will probably be a purchaser for some time. On this case, I consider a contrarian strategy of promoting or shorting the inventory can pay dividends (though I am fairly certain the corporate will not).

firm background

Primarily based in San Mateo, CA, Guidewire develops software program merchandise for property and casualty insurers. The corporate additionally gives associated implementation {and professional} providers. The corporate is attempting to maneuver in the direction of a subscription mannequin from license gross sales. It has been unprofitable for the final three years, with losses rising yearly. The inventory is down greater than 40% within the final 12 months, in comparison with a 15% drop within the S&P 500.

monetary overview

For the most recent quarter ending July 31, 2022, the corporate generated $245 million in income, up 7% YoY. Working earnings was a lack of $32 million (-13% working margin), and internet earnings was a lack of $31 million or $0.37 per share. This quarter was additionally the tip of its fiscal 12 months, and the corporate confirmed income of $813 million, up 9% YoY. Working earnings was a lack of $199 million (-24% working margin) and internet earnings was a lack of $180 million or $2.16 per share.

The corporate presently has 84 million shares and a market capitalization of $5.1 billion. It has $358 million of debt and $1.16 billion of money for internet money of $0.8 billion. It thus has an enterprise worth of $4.3 billion, amounting to 4.6x its annual income.

Analysts anticipate the corporate to proceed rising at a ten% price, with its losses maintained. The corporate’s steerage is for about $900 million in income for the approaching 12 months. The corporate has not provided a path to GAAP profitability.

Valuation and suggestion

Per the conservative approach I worth loss-making firms, I assume that Guidewire will in the end develop into worthwhile. I’m modeling a ten% working margin, transferring up from -24% in its final fiscal 12 months. One necessary level is that I don’t ignore inventory compensation. If you don’t consider it is a actual expense, then you might cease studying now! Most administration groups nonetheless have their head within the sand with their pondering that they will compensate their staff with as a lot inventory as they need with no antagonistic results. This represents a chance for bearish buyers, as staff will probably be always promoting their shares.

A ten% margin on $900 million of annual income would imply annualized revenue of $$90 million a 12 months. I worth the corporate at a 28x a number of on this revenue. I consider that is cheap. A top quality firm like Microsoft (MSFT) with an analogous progress price trades at 24x this 12 months’s EPS. I’m not making use of a tax price to the earnings to be conservative as the corporate has an gathered deficit of $284 million that may protect just a few years’ earnings.

I thus worth the corporate at $2.5 billion and add again the online money for a complete fairness worth of $3.3 billion. Dividing by 84 million shares offers a good worth of $39 for the inventory, towards its present $61 worth, for 35% draw back. I like to recommend promoting or shorting the inventory. You may additionally select to promote calls or purchase places as a substitute. I consider most of this draw back will probably be realized over time, as staff maintain promoting their shares and no new cash enters the market.

Quick curiosity and value of borrowing

It might be harmful to brief a inventory that already has a excessive brief curiosity, with the potential for a brief squeeze driving the worth a lot larger. It might even be uneconomical to pay a excessive borrow value that probably eats up all of the draw back on the inventory facet. GTLB has a low brief curiosity at 5% of excellent shares.

GWRE inventory is straightforward to borrow with a minimal borrow value. Relying in your settlement together with your dealer, you might get a brief rebate for the funds generated from promoting the inventory you borrow (normally a reduction of 50-100 bps from the Fed Funds price, presently at 3-3.25%). So you possibly can make 2% a 12 months on any brief proceeds.

exterior scores

In search of Alpha’s synthetic intelligence warns that GWRE is at excessive threat of performing badly based mostly on its quant scores. It has a composite score of 1.64, equating to a promote. Not surprisingly, Wall Avenue analysts are extra optimistic, with a mixed score of three.6, in between a maintain and purchase. Their worth targets have been following the inventory decrease.

Dangers are excessive however manageable

Shorting shares is inherently dangerous, for the reason that potential losses are theoretically infinite. I might suggest having a brief portfolio solely together with lengthy positions. You could considerably lower threat by promoting places towards brief positions, at about 20% decrease than the present worth, producing some earnings, however capping earnings.

If buyers grew to become in love with an organization, there may very well be a brief squeeze. Nevertheless, with cash getting tighter, I might regard the probabilities of this occurring on an prolonged foundation to not be very excessive. The corporate would additionally seemingly challenge fairness in such a situation. Nevertheless, if it points fairness at an inflated worth, that does improve the corporate’s intrinsic worth.

The corporate may very well be acquired at a premium by one other firm or personal fairness fund. This can be a threat that may be diversified by holding numerous brief positions, with each being small. At a $5 billion market cap, an acquisition right here is definitely possible.

The hole between the corporate’s intrinsic worth and share worth may widen over time.

The corporate may drive up its share worth by shopping for again its inventory. Nevertheless, I consider this will probably be simply momentary as it will likely be shopping for its shares above their intrinsic worth.

Pre-emptive disclosure

Writing a brief thesis on a inventory on a public discussion board is an invite for blowback from staff and holders of the inventory. I welcome respectful feedback from eponymous readers. In case you are a holder or worker, you’ll be higher off directing your energies in the direction of having your organization develop into worthwhile.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.