Skip to content

Lawyer charged in relation to spying on Manitoba choose – Winnipeg Free Press

An Alberta lawyer has been charged with obstruction-of-justice offenses almost a 12 months and a half after he admitted to hiring a personal investigator to spy on a Manitoba choose.

John Carpay, founding father of the Calgary-based Justice Heart for Constitutional Freedoms, turned himself in to Calgary police on Dec. 30 after he was knowledgeable a couple of warrant being issued for his arrest, the middle says in an internet assertion.

Gerard Kennedy, assistant professor on the College of Manitoba’s school of legislation, mentioned he has by no means seen a case by which a lawyer confronted prison penalties for his or her actions inside a authorized continuing.


Alberta lawyer John Carpay has been charged with obstruction of justice.

“It’s in all probability not unprecedented, however it’s exceptionally uncommon,” Kennedy mentioned.

“I feel it goes to the seriousness of what Mr. Carpay is alleged to have executed. Having mentioned that, proving that he meant to impede justice past an inexpensive doubt shall be difficult. So, I’m very curious what the whole lot of the police and Crown’s case is.”

On Monday, the Winnipeg Police Service confirmed Carpay, 55, has been charged with intimidation of a justice system participant and making an attempt to impede justice in relation to a plan to trace Manitoba Courtroom of King’s Bench Chief Justice Glenn Joyal. The intent was to see if Joyal obeyed provincial public-health orders whereas he presided over a high-profile authorized problem that sought to have the orders declared unconstitutional.

The police service hasn’t mentioned when the warrant for Carpay’s arrest was issued and did not reply to free press questions Monday.

The investigation, which was began by officers within the main crimes unit in July 2021, stays ongoing.

In its assertion, the Justice Heart for Constitutional Freedoms described the fees as “surprising and with out clarification.”

The middle mentioned it “is deeply disillusioned by the choice of Winnipeg police to put down a prison cost for occasions that befell greater than 18 months in the past and which can be already being handled appropriately. It’s doubly disappointing that it was determined that these actions ought to happen in the course of the vacation season when Mr. Carpay is spending time together with his household.

“Oddly, Mr. Carpay’s sole bail situation states that he can’t contact Chief Justice Joyal, a person that Mr. Carpay has not had any communication with aside from the apologies that he issued in 2021,” the middle acknowledged.

Carpay, who based the libertarian-focused justice heart in 2010, apologized to Joyal throughout a particular courtroom listening to held nearly in July 2021 after the choose found he was being adopted.

The justice heart had backed a constitutional problem launched in Manitoba on behalf of seven church buildings that have been protesting COVID-19 public-health restrictions.

Carpay admitted he employed personal investigators to trace Joyal and unnamed senior Manitoba politicians to see in the event that they have been defending the orders.

The church buildings wished the courtroom to strike down orders, which they argued unfairly restricted non secular freedom by banning or proscribing in-person companies, to forestall transmission of the virus.

Joyal rejected the church buildings’ arguments, and the case was appealed to the Manitoba Courtroom of Enchantment. The enchantment courtroom reserved its determination on Dec. 13, 2022.

The timing of that enchantment could clarify why prison costs have been laid now, almost 18 months later, Kennedy mentioned.

Carpay is licensed to apply legislation in Alberta, and he was investigated by the legislation societies in Alberta and Manitoba.

An expert misconduct listening to for Carpay and Jay Cameron, one other lawyer for the justice centre, is ready to happen Feb. 8 to 10 in relation to the hiring of a personal investigator.

Ottawa lawyer Richard Warman filed misconduct complaints in opposition to Carpay and Cameron following the revelations in Manitoba courtroom in July 2021. The complaints flagged potential grounds for prison costs, and Warman has continued to observe misconduct allegations involving attorneys who work for the justice Centre.

On Monday, Warman mentioned he is not stunned by the fees, however continues to be shocked by the case.

“The concept that a lawyer would assume it was acceptable, in any universe, that they need to go and rent a personal investigator to stalk the chief justice after they’re showing earlier than him — even when they weren’t showing earlier than him…. I feel it could shock any member of the general public. When you’re a lawyer and also you assume that is OK, you’ve got bought severe issues along with your ethics,” Warman mentioned.

Katie May

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *